Fear
Posted by Carol Howard Merritt on 03 Jan 2009 at 07:52 pm | Tagged as: church, pastors
I went to go visit Margery in the hospital. Several years ago, going to see Margery was part of my weekly routine. I always went to her place her, even though… well…. I am a people person, and I really cannot name many people in any of the churches that I have served whom I did not like. I feel really bad admitting this about a a widow in her 80s, but I’ll do it. I will admit to you that I did not like Margery.
I tried, but every time I was around her, she was putting me down for something. I was spending too much money, and I didn’t take care of my daughter, and I was always wearing the wrong clothes.
To make matters even more difficult, the other members of our church listened to Margery and respected her deeply. They told me that she was so critical because I was a woman. She never wanted a woman pastor, and the fact that I was a young woman made it much worse. I had replaced a much older man, an interim who was well past retirement, and she resented the fact that I took away her dear friend.
But, you know, the thing about being a pastor, sometimes it doesn’t really matter if you like someone or not. Sometimes it doesn’t even matter if they like you. Sometimes you just need to be with them.
It was one of those mornings. I went to see Margery in the hospital, right after the doctor had visited her. He came to tell her that the cancer that they were hoping to contain had just spread all over her body, and many of her vital organs. She didn’t have much longer. She was going to die.
I was the first one to see her after she heard the news. So, I read the Psalms with her. We prayed together. When I said amen, Margery could barely talk, so she said, “Carol, come here. Come closer so I can tell you something.”
I sat on the edge of her bed and put my ear next to her mouth. Her voice suddenly came back strong as she said, “Couldn’t you have found some pearls to wear with that outfit? That sweater looks terrible on you. You know I hate it when you wear black. The neckline is so plain. Just get a drop pearl necklace, really. They don’t cost that much money.”
The next time I went to visit her, she was in a different hospital, telling me about a run-in that she had with her nurse. They fought, and she was replaying the abusive conversation with all of her intensity. And as I listened, something began to swell up inside of me. I told Margery that I needed to leave, and when I exited the room, I began to run. My head was tingling with heat, and I couldn’t wait to get out of the hospital. When I broke out of the doors, I met the winter air with gratitude. Then I went into my car and breathed deeply.
I had always read that people had a fight or flight instinct, but I had never experienced it before that moment.
I used to think that I was not a fearful person at all. In fact, I could not name one thing, situation, or person that I was afraid of. Yet, at that moment, I became afraid of an eighty-year-old woman who was dying of cancer.
Suddenly, I could identify so many things that I feared. I was anxious about the death of loved ones, especially the passing of my grandmother, who was sick at that time. I feared that I would have to make tough decisions about my father’s declining health, decisions that he would not agree with and fight against. And I realized that I had a whole variety of fears there all along. I just didn’t know what that particular sensation was, and I had no idea how to face them. I had assumed that having courage was the same thing as pretending like your fears don’t exist.
Being a pastor can be intensely emotional at times. The vocation has a way of getting under your skin and calling up so many things you thought you would never have to face otherwise. I hope that in the new year, we might have the strength to keep facing the difficulties that might come our way. May we somehow find the courage.


You’re courageous. And the pearl story is almost hilarious (imagine it on screen, with Reese Witherspoon playing you). But in all seriousness, this encounter shows the power of people’s dark sides, and we all have them. Being a pastor just makes us go nose to nose with them, our own, and other people’s, in a way that many people manage to sidestep during the dance of their days.
I have found over the years that members often pick on something like my outfit instead of my theology because of their fears. At my first church, a small group sent a representative to explain to me that dockers was unacceptable to wear to a garden party. After getting over the initial thought “I have only been at this church for a month…how can they already dislike me?” I was able to see the fears that my congregation had because I was not what they were used to having in the pulpit. There was a fear on their part of how to relate to me.
I admire your ability to announce your fears publicly because that is how we get over our fears.
Many blessings to you as you continue to minister in your congregation and to the world through your blog.
You write–But, you know, the thing about being a pastor, sometimes it doesn’t really matter if you like someone or not. Sometimes it doesn’t even matter if they like you. Sometimes you just need to be with them.
OH MY–AMEN!
I once had a woman come into my office and tell me my obesiety prevented her from hearing the Gospel. I was too fat to preach the word of God’s grace. But in that same meeting, she asked me to pray for her because she knew it was wrong. I pray for her and hope to see her again, but I don’t hold my breath I’ll see her again.
I never thought fight and flight have as much to do with fear as they do with being threatened–this lady threatened you and you flew. Remember-as you know-flying is better than slapping her and telling her exactly what she needs to hear. (Though that would by a fine day dream.)
I agree with Martha and Ruth–you’re brave. It’s brave to take on the world when threats abound, and it’s even brave to flee when that’s the better option.
Paul, Really? Someone said that? Ugh. How painful. I’m so sorry.
I guess you’re right. Flying isn’t the worst thing, is it?
Ruth, actually, we did get a lot of laughs from the pearl necklace encounter. We still do.
And Martha, thanks.
Carol, thank you for so honestly describing that feeling of suffocation that people can sometimes bring out in us — a feeling we know as pastors we’re not “supposed to” feel. But oh, we do.
I had an ‘aha’ moment a few weeks ago when I was asking a friend if she would attend a visitation for a mutual acquaintance –a woman our age –who had just died of cancer. She replied “No, I can’t,” and I knew in that answer that it had nothing to do with her availability.
Of course, I realized. Many people draw away from death and suffering. I just have been conditioned, as a pastor, to draw closer at those very times when a normal human response might be to protect myself and my own emotions.
I just can’t let my conditioning get in the way of my recognizing that I still feel that fear — it’s part of what makes me human.
I’ve read this twice, and it made me wince. I start my Pastoral Ministry rotation this month, and I enjoy reading everything that you write. Even in facing her death with all the trappings to go with it, she took the time to critique your dress and your abilities. I find that laughable but serious.
This isn’t the first time you have had run ins with the ‘elders’ at your church I wonder how many of the others that respected her so much would do the same to you if they were in her shoes. Resentments can run deep, I guess it is our vocation to see past them and find the nugget of “Grace” in all that ridicule. It seems that she knew just where your buttons and insecurities lay. There is a nugget of truth for you. She knew just where to hit you.
You replaced someone who must have been a pinnacle of faith for her and it seemed that you did not own the right, in her words, to minister to her like he would have in that same instance. We can’t be all people to everyone I guess. But you showed up and you said your prayers, even if she lobbed a bomb afterwards.
I don’t have the practical experience you have under your belt, but I admire your courage to speak truth to the rest of us. We may not like everyone we minister to, but God loves them all just the same. And I am sure in your truth, God loves you anyways, just because…
One day I might have a story to tell someone and be able to teach grace like you have here.
Jeremy
I have to agree with Ruth. You are one of the most courageous people I’ve ever met and I’ve known you a long time.